 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
 |
|
|
 |
|
|
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
 |
|
|
 |
|
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
  Scott Weinberg:
I worked on this list for hours before I realized that there's no way to squeeze 50 favorites into 20 slots. I'm tortured by the films I had to leave out.
|
   Ajoutez un commentaire sur cette liste
Ðarth Riddle a écrit le 17 mars 2006
Good list, check out mine.
Aramand Grant a écrit le 11 mars 2006
That is a very vulgar list.
The range in quality is enourmous and mostly are nothing but entertainment. I have noticed that you gave merit to "Dark City" over "Matrix".
JOHN SMITH III a écrit le 30 janvier 2005
It took you hours to realize you can't fit 50 movies in 20 slots? What a waste! I could only imagine what a waste might have been to watch some of them.
Scott Weinberg a écrit le 19 novembre 2004
Thanks, Ms. Sparrow. My best to Cap'n Jack!
Marissa Sparrow a écrit le 19 novembre 2004
Great list!!
Scott Weinberg a écrit le 12 novembre 2004
Wow, thanks Mike! Very nice of you to notice! ;)
Michael Browne a écrit le 12 novembre 2004
Whoever would begrudge "Moulin Rouge" hasn't the capacity to be swept away by pure movie magic. This is a powerful list, and lemme just say that you're one of the most insightful, reliable, down-to-earth, and entertaining critics on Hollywood Bitchslap/efilmcritic (you, Childress, and Collin Souter), so it endears me even more to you to see the marvelous "Young Frankenstein" in your #1 spot, with "The Princess Bride", "MR", "Airplane!", "Jaws" and so many classic others below it. I would marry you if California wasn't so puritanical about that sort of thing
Scott Weinberg a écrit le 10 octobre 2004
Thanks, Kurt & Chris.
Kurt Wagner (regular favourites) a écrit le 10 octobre 2004
I don't think I can say I hate any of these films. Great list.
melvin smiley a écrit le 1 octobre 2004
Great choices - Fight Club, Brazil, Godfather, Raising Arizona, Young Frankenstein, Raiders, Airplane, Princess Bride! :-)
Scott Weinberg a écrit le 2 aout 2004
Sorry guys! MR stays. I know it's an odd choice, but I love the crazy thing.
Christopher Meder a écrit le 30 juillet 2004
aye would be a better list minus Moulin Rouge!
Scott Weinberg a écrit le 23 juillet 2004
Thanks guys. I'll be sure to check out your lists and tell you where you're right and where you're insane. ;)
David Caughran a écrit le 23 juillet 2004
Nice list. Young Frankenstien or Blazing Saddles, that was my conundrum.
Gabe White a écrit le 18 juillet 2004
It's good to see Dark City and Brazil up there, as well as the coen's.
Aldo Iannotti a écrit le 13 juillet 2004
Really a good list
Omar Thorarensen a écrit le 28 juin 2004
Kick ass list
I´m glad to see Fight club and Seven on the top 20, brilliant movies.... Check out my list!!!CHEERS!
Ryan Clark a écrit le 6 juin 2004
Great choices with Young Frankenstein, Jaws, The Thing, Halloween, and Fight Club. However, last time I saw Alien I was quite disappointing, having loved it the first time I saw it. While technically well made, it was very dull.
JOHN SMITH III a écrit le 26 mai 2004
Good, American movies. Special note for Brazil.
Scott Weinberg a écrit le 19 novembre 2003
Thanks guys!
suivant >>
Pour accéder à tous les commentaires que ce membre a laissé sur les pages de film, cliquez ici |
